You've seen it dangling from him since his birth. It's something we have had our hard times with, but overall are so grateful for. We love the binki, but it was time for it to go.

It's funny how much guilt a parent can have. For example, my neighbor has been telling me for the last month, "Maren, this is the last bottle you will see Isaiah have." Do I care that he uses a bottle to drink his milk (at 15 months), heck no, but she sure does. This is how I have felt about Braden's binki for the past 4 months. I am sure my neighbor heard me say a thousand times, "When vacations are overs... or When Braden's 18 months ..." Well, about a month ago, the time finally arrived. Blake wanted me to write this down so we'd remember for the next one.
After we got back from Coeur d'Alene we decided we needed to make a plan. After hearing all sorts of advice, we decided we would limit the areas of use until we got down to just nap/bedtime. We figured this would take several weeks. Well, the day came around when we were going to start. (We decided to start with the binki only in the house.) I went in to get Braden in the morning and decided, I was sick of seeing it and worrying about it all day. I asked Braden to place his binki on his bed. And that's where it has been ever since.
The first week he would ask for the binki throughout the day. We would sweetly remind him that it's only for nigh nighs. I am proud to say we have gone binki free (minus naps & bedtime) for the past month. We are so glad we don't have the panic of, "Did you grab the binki?" He has been great.
As for completely eliminating the binki, it doesn't bother us at all, as long as he's in his crib. Once he's asleep, it falls out within a minute, so we are in no hurry to fully eliminate it. I am sure we will do it before the baby comes, but as for now, you have guilt free parents on your hand.